Listed by Dolan Real Estate · Sam Schwarz · Cell: 603-456-8607

1 / 30

Single Family Residence · Sutton, NH

ActiveFor SalePrice Reduced

14 Grist Mill Street, Sutton, NH

$699,900

$724,000 · changed Sep 7, 2026

Est. $3,539/mo · 20% down, 30-yr, 6.5% (Owl’s Nest Real Estate estimate, not MLS data)

Beds
4
Baths
5
Sq Ft
3,168
Built
1857
MLS®
#5087255

Property Description

Offered at $699,900, this Sutton single-family home at 14 Grist Mill Street pairs New Hampshire living with everyday convenience. It counts 4 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms and 3,168 square feet of living space. The format is the classic one — a standalone home with no association between you and your plans for it. Beyond the basics, the listing carries a 3.98-acre lot, garage parking for 1 and 1857 construction. Everything below — photos, details, schools and market data — updates live from the MLS.

Open House Saturday 10/10 from 12 to 2PM. Step into a piece of New Hampshire history. Built in 1857 and once cherished as a bed & breakfast, this captivating 4-bed, 5-bath Sutton property has been thoughtfully updated while preserving the charm that makes it truly irreplaceable. The natural separation between the main home and attached carriage house creates exceptional flexibility — multi-generational living, rental income, or an in-home business are all within reach. With the barn, garage, and art studio, ADU conversion potential adds even more to this already remarkable offering. The property features apple, peach, pear, plum, and nectarine trees alongside blueberry bushes — a homesteader's dream taking root right in your backyard. Recent updates deliver real peace of mind: new septic & leach field (11/25), new burner (2022), partial roof (2022), updated first-floor bath (3/26), new appliances, new washer & dryer, fresh interior paint throughout, new kitchen plumbing, wood stove (2018), two relined chimneys, new well pump, new well supply line, and electrical supply upgrade. Whether you're searching for a one-of-a-kind primary home, a savvy investment, or the chance to revive a beloved B&B — this is the opportunity you've been waiting for. All of this, just 45 minutes to Manchester and 90 minutes to Boston. Portions of the property may be subject to historic access easements/right-of-way benefiting neighboring landowners. Schedule your private showing today.

Location Highlights

14 Grist Mill Street is a single family residence in Sutton, New Hampshire, listed at $699,900. That works out to about $221 per square foot, for a home built in 1857. It has been on the market for 6 months.

From here it is 31.7 miles to Downtown Plymouth / Main Street and 39.9 miles to Owl's Nest Resort. At this latitude, Sutton averages roughly 8.4 hours of sun a day in June and 3.6 in December.

Zoned schools in the Kearsarge Sch Dst SAU #65: Kearsarge Regional Middle Sch (Middle), KearsargeR (High). Always confirm zoning with the district office.

Source: zoned school names are PrimeMLS listing data; distances, sun exposure and school facts are Owl’s Nest Real Estate additions (school facts from the NCES, U.S. Department of Education) — not PrimeMLS data.

Property Details

Essentials & finishes

Bedrooms
4
Total Baths
5
Full Baths
4
SqFt
3,168
Price / SqFt
$220.93
Property Type
Single Family Residence
Year Built
1857
County
NH-Merrimack
Town
Sutton, NH
Status
Active
Days on Market
164

Primary Features

County
NH-Merrimack
Property Type
Residential
Year Built
1857
Zoning
Village

Interior Features

Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer, Range Hood, Microwave, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Gas Stove
Basement
Yes
Basement Access Type
Interior
Basement Description
Interior Entry, Interior Stairs, Unfinished
1/4 Baths
0
3/4 Baths
0
Cooling
Attic Fan
Electric
200+ Amp Service, Circuit Breakers
Flooring
Carpet, Ceramic Tile, Softwood, Tile, Vinyl
Heating
Baseboard, Forced Air, Oil, Wood, 2 Stoves, Wood Stove
Interior Features
Ceiling Fan(s), Dining Area, Wood Fireplace, 1 Fireplace, In-Law Floorplan, Kitchen Island, Kitchen/Dining, Primary BR w/ BA, Natural Light, Soaking Tub, Wet Bar, Wood Stove Hook-up, 1st Floor Laundry, Walkup Attic
Rooms - Total
14
SqFt-Approximate Finished Above Grade
3,168
SqFt-Approximate Finished Below Grade
0
SqFt Approximate Total Finished
3,168
SqFt Approximate Total
5,192

Location Information

School - District
Kearsarge Sch Dst SAU #65
School - High
KearsargeR
School - Middle/Jr
Kearsarge Regional Middle Sch

Financial Details

Cable Company
TDS
Electric Company
Eversource
Fuel Company
Huckleberry, Ayer & Goss
Tax - Gross Amount
$9,983
Tax Year
2025
Taxes TBD
No

Additional

Construction Status
Existing
Construction
Clapboard, Wood Frame
Covenants
No
Easements
Unknown
Flood Zone
Unknown
Pre-Construction
No
Property Sub Type
Single Family Residence
Resort
No
Seasonal
No
Total Stories
Two
Surveyed
Unknown
Timeshare/Fractional Ownership
No

External Features

Color
White
Driveway
Gravel
Exterior Features
Barn, Garden, Storage
Foundation
Concrete, Concrete Slab, Stone
Garage
Yes
Garage Capacity
1
Lot Features
Pasture, Hilly, Open Lot, Secluded, Neighborhood, Rural, Private
Lot - Acres
3.98
Lot - SqFt
173,369
Road Frontage Type
Dead End, Paved, Public Maintained Road, Public
Road Frontage
Yes
Road Frontage Length
491
Roof
Asphalt Shingle
Sewer
1250 Gallon, Leach Field, Private, Septic Tank
Utilities
Cable Available, Propane
Water Source
Drilled Well, Private

MLS®: PrimeMLS #5087255; Listed by Dolan Real Estate · Sam Schwarz · Cell: 603-456-8607

Property History

Estimated annual taxes for this property

2024
$11,898
2023
$11,601
2022
$11,303

Source: Owl’s Nest Real Estate estimate from the list price at New Hampshire’s average effective tax rate — not PrimeMLS or town assessor data. Verify with the town assessor.

Market Data

Live snapshot computed by Owl’s Nest Real Estate from PrimeMLS IDX active listings in this town

Active listings in Sutton
25
Average list price
$573,558
Price range
$84,000 – $1,495,000

Mortgage Calculator

Estimate your monthly payment for this home

Loan Term

Estimated Monthly Payment

$4,676/ mo

Principal & Interest
$3,539
Property Tax
$992
Home Insurance
$146

Source: Owl’s Nest Real Estate estimate, not PrimeMLS data. Estimates use typical New Hampshire costs — a 1.7% effective property-tax rate, insurance at 0.25% of home value/yr, and PMI below 20% down. Actual town tax rates vary; verify with your lender and the town assessor.

Around This Property

Schools, everyday places and nearby destinations near 14 Grist Mill Street, Sutton, NH

Assigned Schools

Middle
Kearsarge Regional Middle Sch
High School
KearsargeR
District
Kearsarge Sch Dst SAU #65

Source: Google Maps Platform (Places) and Owl’s Nest Real Estate — not PrimeMLS data.

Questions About This Listing

How much does 14 Grist Mill Street cost?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH is listed for $699,900 on PrimeMLS.

That is about $221 per square foot of finished living space.

It came on the market on May 6, 2026.

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 14 Grist Mill Street have?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH has 4 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms (4 full and 1 half) in 3,168 square feet of finished living space.

Does 14 Grist Mill Street have a basement?

Yes. 14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH has a basement with interior access.

The MLS describes it as interior entry, interior stairs and unfinished.

What are the key features of 14 Grist Mill Street?

Inside, the MLS lists these features at 14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH: ceiling fan(s), dining area, wood fireplace, 1 fireplace, in-law floorplan, kitchen island, kitchen/dining and primary BR w/ BA.

Outside: barn, garden and storage.

Flooring: carpet, ceramic tile, softwood, tile and vinyl.

Listed appliances: dishwasher, dryer, range hood, microwave, gas range, refrigerator, washer and gas stove; confirm which ones convey in the purchase agreement.

What parking does 14 Grist Mill Street have?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH has a 1-car garage and a gravel driveway.

What school district is 14 Grist Mill Street in?

The MLS places 14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH in the Kearsarge Sch Dst SAU #65.

Listed schools: Kearsarge Regional Middle Sch (middle) and KearsargeR (high).

School assignments can change; confirm with the district.

Is 14 Grist Mill Street still for sale?

Yes. 14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH is listed as Active on PrimeMLS (MLS #5087255).

Status can change quickly; contact us to confirm availability before you visit.

Which brokerage has 14 Grist Mill Street listed?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH is listed by Sam Schwarz of Dolan Real Estate (603-763-6033).

Owl's Nest Real Estate shows it through the PrimeMLS IDX feed; we are not the listing brokerage.

What type of home is 14 Grist Mill Street?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH is a single-family home built in 1857.

The MLS lists its style as Cape, Carriage, Historic Vintage, with two stories.

What town is 14 Grist Mill Street in?

14 Grist Mill Street is in Sutton, New Hampshire 03260, in Merrimack County.

What is the lot size of 14 Grist Mill Street?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH sits on 3.98 acres, per the MLS.

The lot is described as pasture, hilly, open lot, secluded, rural and private.

It has 491 feet of road frontage (dead end, paved, public maintained road and public).

Zoning: Village.

What are the annual property taxes for 14 Grist Mill Street?

Annual property taxes on 14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH are $9,983 for the 2025 tax year, per the MLS.

New Hampshire towns set their own tax rates and revalue periodically, so confirm the current bill with the Sutton assessing office.

What heating and cooling does 14 Grist Mill Street have?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH is heated by baseboard, forced air, oil, wood, 2 stoves and wood stove, per the MLS.

Cooling: attic fan.

What are the water and sewer systems at 14 Grist Mill Street?

14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH has a private drilled well and a private septic system, per the MLS.

MLS details — water: drilled well and private; sewer: 1250 gallon, leach field, private and septic tank.

Electric: 200+ amp service and circuit breakers (Eversource).

Other utilities: cable available and propane; cable provider TDS.

Plan a water test and septic inspection during your inspection period.

How does the price of 14 Grist Mill Street compare with other Sutton listings?

At $699,900, 14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH is priced above the $574,950 median asking price of the 14 single-family homes for sale in Sutton on PrimeMLS as of November 3, 2026 (this listing included).

That figure is Owl's Nest Real Estate's analysis of active listings, and asking prices are not sale prices — ask us for recent comparable sales before you make an offer.

How can I see 14 Grist Mill Street in person?

To see 14 Grist Mill Street in Sutton, NH, use Request a Showing on this page or call Owl's Nest Real Estate at 401-648-5308.

We can show any MLS-listed home and represent you as your buyer's agent; the listing brokerage represents the seller.

Similar Listings in Sutton

PrimeMLS

NOTE: This representation is based in whole or in part on data generated by PrimeMLS, Inc., which assumes no responsibility for its accuracy. The data relating to real estate displayed on this site comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS.

This listing data is intended for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated 11/03/26.