Is a CMA the Same as an Appraisal?

Buying Guides

Is a CMA the Same as an Appraisal?

November 4, 2026

Tom DeMatteo

Written by Tom DeMatteo

Broker/Owner, Owl's Nest Real Estate · · 5 min read

A CMA is not the same as an appraisal. A comparative market analysis (CMA) is a real estate agent's opinion of a likely price, built from recent nearby sales, while an appraisal is a formal valuation by an appraiser licensed or certified under New Hampshire's RSA 310-B, and it is the value a mortgage lender uses to decide how much it will lend.

A buyer sees the CMA before the offer and the appraisal after the contract is signed. Our New Hampshire home buyer guide shows where each one falls.

On this page

What is the difference between a CMA and a house appraisal?

The difference between a CMA and a house appraisal is who prepares it, who it is for, and what it can be used for. A CMA is prepared by a licensed real estate agent for a buyer or seller, usually free, to set an offer or a list price. An appraisal is prepared by a state-licensed appraiser, usually for a lender, for a fee, and it is the number that underwriting relies on.

CMA (comparative market analysis) Appraisal
Prepared by Licensed real estate agent (RSA 331-A) Licensed or certified appraiser (RSA 310-B)
Usually ordered by Buyer or seller, through their agent Mortgage lender
Purpose Choose an offer or list price Support the loan amount
Includes active and pending listings Yes, alongside closed sales Closed sales lead the analysis
Cost Usually free Paid by the buyer, usually at or before closing

New Hampshire law draws the line explicitly. RSA 310-B:3 says the appraiser licensing chapter does not apply to a real estate licensee preparing a comparative market analysis or broker price opinion as an activity regulated by the NH Real Estate Commission. A CMA can be very good, but it can't stand in for a licensed appraisal on a mortgage.

Why can a CMA and an appraisal of the same house differ?

A CMA and an appraisal of the same house can differ because they read the market at different moments and with different rules. A CMA looks forward: it weighs closed sales together with what is listed and under agreement now, and an agent's judgment of how buyers are reacting. An appraisal looks back at closed, verifiable sales and adjusts each one for differences such as size, land, condition and location.

The CMAs real estate agents prepare here draw on closed sales in PrimeMLS, the multiple listing service covering New Hampshire. The gap is widest in thin markets, which describes much of this area. A lakefront house on Squam or Newfound, a hill farm in Campton or a contemporary in Waterville Valley may have only two or three truly comparable sales in a year, so the appraiser reaches further back in time or further away in distance. That is where an appraisal can land below an agreed price. Views and frontage are hard to price from a handful of sales; the guide on whether a view increases home value looks at that problem.

What happens if the appraisal comes in lower than the offer?

If the appraisal comes in lower than the offer, the lender bases the loan on the lower value, so the buyer either brings more cash, negotiates the price down, asks for a reconsideration with better comparable sales, or cancels under the appraisal contingency within its deadline. Which of those is available depends on how the purchase and sales agreement is written.

That is why the CMA matters to buyers too. Before an offer we pull the closed sales an appraiser is likely to use. In the Plymouth area, our buyer's guide to offers and inspections covers how a low appraisal interacts with FHA, VA and conventional loans. Our answer on what a P&S is explains how the appraisal contingency and its deadline work.

Frequently asked questions

Is a CMA house appraisal accurate?

A CMA house appraisal is really a price opinion, and its accuracy depends on how many good comparable sales exist and how well the agent adjusts for differences. In active markets with many similar homes it is usually close to the appraised value; in thin rural and lakefront markets the range is wider. For a quick starting point, try our free home valuation, then ask us for a full CMA.

Is an appraisal the same as the tax assessed value?

An appraisal is not the same as the tax assessed value. The assessed value is set by the town for property tax and can lag the market for years between revaluations, while an appraisal values the house as of a single date. Our answer on the tax assessed value of a home in NH explains the difference.

Who pays for the appraisal when buying a house in NH?

The buyer usually pays for the appraisal when buying a house in NH with a mortgage, even though the lender orders it and the appraiser works for the lender. The fee is often collected upfront or shown on the closing statement. A cash buyer can skip the appraisal, though many order one anyway on a unique property.